Home Articles What are the pros and cons of Medicare Advantage (Part C) plans?

What are the pros and cons of Medicare Advantage (Part C) plans?

What is a Medicare Advantage Plan? 

Medicare Advantage plans, also referred to as Part C of Medicare, is the name of an insurance plan which is offered by private insurance companies. When you elect to have a Medicare Advantage plan, the private insurance company replaces your Medicare coverage from the government. 

The same private insurance companies that sell Medicare Advantage plans sell Medicare Supplements, which can be confusing. These are companies such as Humana, AARP UnitedHealthcare, Cigna, Blue Cross and Blue Shield, and many more.  Just make sure to be clear on what option you are looking at. 

To make this election, you must first be enrolled in Part A and Part B of Medicare. You are still responsible for paying the monthly premium for Part B ($144.60 in 2020 for most), even on a Medicare Advantage plan. 

By law, Medicare Advantage plan’s benefits must be equivalent, if not better, than Original Medicare under law. 

Medicare Advantage plans make your Medicare act a lot like the coverage that most people get through work before age 65. The private insurance company covers you, you have co-payments and deductibles, and you have to go to doctors in the plans network. We break down who these plans do and do not work well for below! 

What are the pros of a Medicare Advantage plan? 

There are many people that a Medicare Advantage plan really works well for.  For them, these pros outright the cons: 


  • Medicare Advantage plans include drug coverage
    Unlike a Medicare Supplement, where you have to get a separate drug plan, almost all Medicare Advantage plans are going to include drug coverage.That means you do not have to go out and purchase a separate plan just to cover your drugs.


  • Medicare Advantage plans include extras like dental, vision, hearing, and wellness benefits
    Many Medicare Advantage plans include extra benefits. This includes limited dental, vision, and hearing coverage. If you are on a Medicare Supplement, you are going to have to buy coverage for these in a separate plan.

    Some Medicare Advantage plans include wellness benefits, such as SilverSneakers, or an equivalent, that will pay for your gym membership. 
    While we don’t advocate for making a decision about your Medicare coverage based solely on these extra benefits, they are great additions to any plan.


What are the cons of a Medicare Advantage plan? 

With the lower price and extra benefits that Medicare Advantage plans offer, there are some requirements and restrictions that you must be aware of. 

  • Medicare Advantage plans have networks
    For most people who do not end up with a Medicare Advantage plan, this is the reason. Medicare Advantage plans require you to go to their doctors and their hospitals, while Medicare Supplements allow you to go to any doctor that accepts Medicare.

    While for some, networks are going to be no problem, if you are someone who wants to possibly visit specialists or travel in retirement, a Medicare Advantage plan is not going to work well. Due to the networks, which are based on your zip code, Advantage plans do not travel well.

    While some Medicare Advantage plans allow you to go out-of-network for an additional cost (PPOs), some plans do not pay for anything at all if you go out-of-network (HMO). This can get very very expensive.

    Make sure to consider the networks before signing up for a Medicare Advantage plan.


  • Medicare Advantage plans are hard to compare
    Medicare Supplements are standardized, Medicare Advantage plans are not. They are going to vary on monthly premiums, deducticles, copayments, drug costs, and extra benefits.

    What is offered is also going to vary greatly by your location. Advantage plans are based on zip code. Some zip codes are going to have 10+ plans, some are going to have none.

    You are also going to want to make sure that all the doctors you absolutely want are going to be in the network of the plan you pick. This means you need to check the network of every single plan you are considering.

    For these reasons, Medicare Advantage plans are really hard to compare.


  • You can only switch Medicare Advantage plans during Annual Enrollment
    With Medicare Supplements, you can change your plan anytime of the year. With Medicare Advantage plans, you can only change your plan one time per year,and only during the annual open enrollment period. This occurs from October 15th – December 7th every year.


  • Plans can change their drug and medical coverage every year
    It is important to shop your options every year because it is highly likely that the plan you are on is going to change.

    Right before annual open enrollment, plans evaluate and change their networks and drug formularies. Many times, your doctor could be moved out-of-network and your drugs could be made more expensive.

    You need to make sure in the fall of every year that everything you need to be covered is going to be.

Even with the cons, we do not want to seem like we are making Medicare Advantage plans out to be bad. Like we said, Advantage plans work really great for many of our clients, but we have to make sure that the limitations of these plans work for their situation.

Make sure to shop around and work with a broker who sells for many companies when looking into Medicare Advantage plans. You need to know all your options to make sure you find the plan that fits the best for your life. 

If you are thinking a Medicare Supplement might be the route for you, you can read more about those plans here


Listen To Finishing Well on Truth

Newest Live Episodes of Finishing Well are on The Truth Network

Finishing Well
Finishing Wellhttps://www.cardinalguide.com/finishing-well/
Retirement planning involves a lot more than just managing your money. This show is the complete guide to planning for and living in retirement, helping families finish well. Host Hans Scheil will discuss a new topic every week ranging from Social Security and Medicare to IRAs and taxes. Follow along each week by downloading the corresponding chapters below for free! New episodes air: Finishing Well Schedule on Truth Network
- Advertisment -

Recent Posts

Free to Choose, Part 2

To support this ministry financially, visit: https://www.oneplace.com/donate/222/29 When God gave us the freedom to choose, it came with the freedom to choose wrong. Join Dr....

Lights In A Dark World IV – Part 2 of 2

“That ye may be blameless and harmless, the sons of God, without rebuke, in the midst of a crooked and perverse nation, among whom ye shine as lights in the world” (Philippians 2:15).

05.12.21 Insights from a Former Member of the CIA

The Line of Fire Radio Broadcast for 05/12/21.

Sheep among Wolves: What to Expect, Part 3

The King’s Kingdom: A Study of Matthew 8–13

Understanding the Root of Your Child’s Misbehavior (Part 1 of 2)

Dr. Kevin Leman offers advice to help parents transform their child’s behavior. He discusses the benefits of allowing your kids to learn from real-life...

A Good Servant of Christ Jesus (Banner of Truth) (Part 1 of 2)

The apostle Paul took Timothy under his wing and encouraged, taught, and counseled him in ministry. What expectations did Paul lay out for this young pastor? Hear the answer when you listen to Truth For Life with Alistair Begg. Listen...

Just Do It: Providing Discipleship to New Believers

Ever been hunting for something in one of those big department stores . . . and you feel like you’ve been walking forever? You...